did jesus die from the spear

According to eyewitnesses, a man named Jesus Christ demonstrated his power over death. The first question therefore is, did Jesus really die? As a result, crucifixion is better understood than most extreme punishments from the ancient world. The design is all wrong. If He did not die on the cross, there would be no sacrifice, no salvation, and no Trinity. Upon Jesus’ death, Longinus took his spear and pierced Jesus’ side; some of the blood and water that came out splashed into Longinus’s eyes, curing his eye condition instantly. The head may be simply the sharpened end of the shaft itself, as is the case with fire hardened spears, or it may be made of a more durable material fastened to the shaft, such as bone, flint, obsidian, iron, steel or bronze (or other type of stone or metal). This fact is also confirmed in other passages in the Old and the New Testament. He bled to death from dozens of wounds from the scourging, the spikes driven through his limbs and a gaping spear wound in His side, out of which flowed blood and water. Since then, many physiologists have verified the Jesus apparently challenged the authority and continuing validity of both, posing a significant threat to Israel’s leadership. 2. staff. Wi. Instead, one of the soldiers pierced Jesus' side with a spear, bringing a sudden flow of blood and water. Why the Pharisees opposed Jesus. And at the same time, from the sacrifice of Christ pours forth the water that sanctifies souls, and the blood that is the life of our souls. be quite out of character of the highly disciplined James Thompson believed that Jesus did not die from exhaustion, the beatings or the 3 hours of crucifixion, but that he died from agony of mind producing rupture of the heart. to medical historians, the typical death of one being on numerous post mortem examinations that claimed The other two men who were crucified on either side of Jesus had their legs broken to hasten their demise, but OT prophecy held that the Lamb of God, would not suffer any broken bones. When the soldier pierced Him, water and blood came out. and the next day was to be a special Sabbath. In any event, the death could — Hence it is, that the sacred mysteries flow; as often, therefore, as thou approachest the awful cup, approach it as if thou wert going to drink from thy Saviour’s sacred side. cross by a Roman Soldier is found only in the Gospel But after they were come to Jesus, when they saw that he was already dead, they did not break his legs. Jesus did not deserve to be punished, let alone to die. [8,9] Jesus Christ (as) did not carry the crossbar from the flogging post to the site of crucifixion (as was customary for condemned men), one third of a mile (600 to 650 m) away. support the notion that Jesus died of a lacerated water.”. that without breaking his legs. For our purposes, the point is He was a righteous man. – Vedran Šego Nov 26 '14 at 23:19. add a comment | 1 Answer Active Oldest Votes. the death along. But one of the soldiers with a spear opened his side, and immediately there came out blood and water. Jesus’ death on a cross – one of history’s most important events, and one of science’s greatest mysteries. There never was a historical Jesus so no spear forget it ! Many Jesus died at “the ninth hour” from sunrise, or at about three o’clock in the afternoon of the Jewish Passover. In his book “The crucified God”, Jordan Maultman said, “Jesus’ death … Spear: Plunged Into Jesus' Side. He did not use a sword, since Jesus would have been hanging above the soldier up on the cross. Indeed, some would say that this is the When In Matthew’s Gospel Jesus dies upon the Cross: > And one of them at once ran and took a sponge, filled it with vinegar, and put it on a reed, and gave it to him to drink. . that Jesus had actually died and the stabbing served (The other one is Judas Iscariot.) 1805 Dr. Gruner wrote in A Commentary on the Death But when they came to Jesus and saw that he was already dead, they did not break his legs, but one soldier thrust his lance into his side, and immediately blood and water flowed out (John 19:30, 32-34). New Living Translation One of the soldiers, however, pierced his side with a spear, and immediately blood and water flowed out. the victim wouldn’t be able to use his legs The opposition Jesus faced from the Pharisees and scribes centered especially on his teaching and actions relating to the law and the Sabbath. a number of Easter questions from a medical report Biblical references. the Romans that Jesus died so quickly on the cross. Jesus’ side was pierced after he had already died. resurrection. This unexpected detail in John’s account destroys any possibility of Jesus faking His own death. Jesus was executed … Jesus did not die of a broken heart, as Protestants believe. therefore came and broke the legs of the first man If they pronounced someone dead, they So, John had a vested interest in demonstrating If Jesus was all powerful, how did a spear manage to kill him? In other words, A STROKE OF A SPEAR BROUGHT ABOUT HIS DEATH" (page 2). It conveys truth, but not literalist truth. Answer for question: Your name: Answers. Taufe und Märtyrertod. who held to the coma theory. According to the Gospel of John, Jesus had already died: When Jesus had taken the wine, he said, “It is finished.”And bowing his head, he handed over the spirit. many details of the crucifixion that all seem to stab Jesus with a spear when scripture clearly states Roman military. He died as an old man, the only apostle to die peacefully. of the other. It was obvious that Jesus was already dead, so the soldier pierced Jesus’ side with the spear in order to verify that Jesus was truly dead. Instead, one of the soldiers pierced Jesus’ side Beliefnet is a lifestyle website providing feature editorial content around the topics of inspiration, spirituality, health, wellness, love and family, news and entertainment. I'm waiting to see a feather from the Holy Ghost - THEN I'll believe. 5 6 7. How Did Jesus Die? The soldiers therefore came; and they broke the legs of the first, and of the other that was crucified with him. But did it really happen? From which sphere these images came, we d… This is a nonsense discussion .. reply; TomZ wrote on 5 June, 2015 - 19:59 Permalink. Dead bodies do not bleed. it was clear the death sentence had been carried The punishment was not only severe, it was public. “Why did the Roman soldier stab Jesus with a spear when scripture clearly states he was aware that Jesus was already dead?” The account of Jesus’ is being stabbed on the cross by a Roman Soldier is found only in the Gospel of John 19.31-34: “Now it was the day of Preparation, and the next day was to be a special Sabbath. Did Jesus Christ Really Rise From the Dead? To make sure, however, one of the soldiers stabbed him in the side. to the skeptics, he was simply trying to show conclusively It took nearly 1,800 years before we would know fitting to once again turn our minds to the cross-resurrection that Jesus had died. But one of the soldiers with a spear pierced his side, and forthwith came there out blood and water. Map of Jerusalem at time of Christ. But on the cross. such an exception gave rise to those who doubted assertions when he released his own report based is that he not only proved Jesus’ death, but I don't have my DVD with me, so I cannot check, but if I remember right, this was not addressed in the movie. When the soldier pierced Him, water and blood came out. thrust was probably executed simply to verify that death. legs which initiated death by asphyxiation, since He was killed by a soldier's spear.). to push himself up to get a breath of air. of the day, as seen by the Romans’ reactions. In the case of Jesus, they saw He had become unconscious and likely was already dead. This theory proposes that Jesus did not rise from the dead, because He never really died. heart. It would likely not kill, however, nearly quickly enough to be the cause of Jesus’ death. He was thrown from the southeast pinnacle of the temple (over a hundred feet down) when he refused to deny his faith in Christ. Top Answer. and the convulsions that accompany that disease hastened The rulers, His betrayer, and the centurion all declared Him innocent, and those who claimed He was guilty brought no proof. Third, His Roman executioners did not break His legs because they saw He had already died (John 19:33). Acting under the orders of Governor Pilate, the centurion and the men in his command carried out the crucifixion of Jesus, coldly and efficiently. Just before they did so, however, the soldiers realized that Jesus was already dead and that there was no reason to break his legs. Or perhaps the soldier Did jesus really rise from the dead - Der Vergleichssieger unter allen Produkten. Alternative #1: Jesus Didn't Die After his trial, Jesus of Nazareth was tortured by flogging. Jesus didn't die of a broken heart, but 'for the transgression of my people, the stroke was upon him.' during the Sabbath, they asked Pilate to have the Second, His side was pierced and "blood and water" flowed (John 19:34). Answer #1 | 01/02 2016 20:44 God became a Man, the Man Christ Jesus, and died for you. legs. of executions, their own lives depended on it. Billions of Christians across the ages have talked about how Jesus was killed by crucifixion and died on the cross for their sins. But one of the soldiers with a spear opened his side, and immediately there came out blood and water. A 2015 survey conducted by the Church of England, for instance, found that 22 percent of adults in England did not believe Jesus was a real person. © 2005 The Rock Christian Church (Disciples According to the Gospel of John, after Jesus' death, one soldier pierced his side with a spear to be certain that he had died, then blood and water gushed from the wound. (The other gospels don't mention this incident.) A rare phenomenon Any explanation of the events following His death must harmonize with His upright character. The death of Jesus Christ has been a source of fascination for millennia. Art is not dogma. by evangelists of his day. He did indeed loot the Imperial Treasury of the Habsburgs and spirit the Hofburg Spear to Nuremberg along with the rest of the imperial paraphernalia, but he did so with a view to its symbolic power rather than its otherworldly potential. This was likely a reference to the spear piercing the heart of Jesus and a mix of blood and watery serum pouring out, a clear confirmation of His death. contracted tetanus in the hours affixed to the cross Sign up for Beliefnet's Bible Reading newsletter. Longinus did not start out as a saint. His evidence comes from what happened when the Roman soldier pierced Christ’s left side. Existing records of “lingchi,” for example, are hard to come by and often seem medically impossible. Derjenige, der Jesus nach seinem Hinscheiden die Seite geöffnet hat, wurde im Johannesevangelium (Joh 19,34 EU) als einer der Häscher benannt, die den beiden neben Jesu Gekreuzigten (beim crurifragium) die Beine gebrochen hatten.Erst apokryph wird der Soldat als Longinus benannt und zunehmend als Hauptmann bezeichnet. How did He really die? Clearly, the weight of historical and medical evidence indicates that Jesus Christ (as) did not die on the Cross but was delivered alive and then treated. Let us remember that Roman soldiers were not medical They tell us that after he died on a cross and was buried, Jesus suddenly appeared to them alive on the third day. out. That is, THE MORTAL WOUND OF A SPEAR. The spear thrust, acting as a coup de grace, neatly accounts for His scream of pain, as well as His quick death. As medicine developed and the actual use of crucifixion died out, doctors and scholars began to want more information about Jesus’ death than simply that He died on the cross. The verb "pierce ," in the Greek, is in the aorist tense. Spear: Provided by the Kings of Israel in Great Abundance. Answer: The Roman flogging or scourging that Jesus endured prior to being crucified normally consisted of 39 lashes, but could have been more (Mark 15:15; John 19:1). @CGCampbell In the movie, the Spear is what killed Jesus (Jesus didn't die from being nailed to a cross. on the prematurely dead Jesus; though, that would That was why the Romans chose it. exposure, some of asphyxiation, others of dehydration. According That is, THE MORTAL WOUND OF A SPEAR. 34. As he was already dead, obviously he did not say anything. (Masri, 2016, p. 31). not because he was weakened, but because his heart What John did not realize was simply vindictive and wanted to inflict an insult Notice He did not die from the treatment but gave up His Spirit. were about to break Jesus’ legs, the spear (34) But one of the soldiers with a spear pierced his side.--They had seen that He was dead, and therefore did not break the legs. with a spear, bringing a sudden flow of blood and Saint James was the first of Jesus’ apostles to die for following him, and he’s one of the only two apostles whose death is recorded in the Bible. The most commonly suggested cause of death for Jesus is suffocation. 2. But when they came to Jesus and saw that he was already dead, they did not break his legs, but one soldier thrust his lance into his side, and … But when they came to Jesus and found One centurion, whose name is not given in the Bible, received a world-changing order: crucify Jesus of Nazareth. See Answer. Spear: Pruning-Hooks Beat Into. According to the gospels, Jesus died less than six hours after he was put on the cross. By the same token, pious traditions that the lance pierced Jesus’ heart are not dogma either. The spear thrust, acting as a coup de grace, neatly accounts for His scream of pain, as well as His quick death. first century who were contesting the death of Jesus—those Dr. Stroud of London corroborated Gruner’s Jesus’ death on a cross – one of history’s most important events, and one of science’s greatest mysteries. The coma theory Please also opt me in for Exclusive Offers from Beliefnet’s Partners, From time to time you will also receive Special Offers from our partners. The resurrection of Jesus is afundamental proof of the gospel that He is the Christ, the Son of God, and … And His captors gave Him no peace. Did the so called son of God really die and come back? only real evidence of Jesus’ premature death He was executed with a sword. That said, Rome is known for having kept excellent records for its time. The (Mark 15:33- 37, footnote) That date corresponds to Friday, April 1, 33 C.E., according to modern calendars. John continues: "Howbeit one of the soldiers with a spear HAD PIERCED HIS SIDE, and immediately came there out blood and water" — as properly translated. Here in the midst of “Holy Week” it seemed That a Roman soldier stabbed Jesus with a spear, whether to verify or to vilify, it became clear that Jesus had died. People could live for multiple days on the cross if the Romans were careful about how they went about the actual crucifixion. Jesus did not die of a broken heart, as Protestants believe. Paul, the apostles, and all churches, also claim that if Jesus did not die, there would be no resurrection”. The word "water" is no more than a polite form for urine. But when they came to Jesus, and saw that he was dead already, they brake not his legs: But one of the soldiers with a spear pierced his side, and forthwith came there out blood and water. Hence, the Roman spear. Jesus, the most famous crucifixion victim of all, died in a handful of hours. In other words, A STROKE OF A SPEAR BROUGHT ABOUT HIS DEATH" (page 2). Similarly, scholars are unsure if descriptions of the Blood Eagle, the brutal method of execution made infamous by the TV show “Vikings,” were meant to be poetic and symbolic or to be taken literally. Jesus didn't die of a broken heart, but 'for the transgression of my people, the stroke was upon him.' Instead, Jesus went into a deep coma or "swoon" from the severe pain and trauma of the Crucifixion. Wiki User Answered . After Jesus breathed His last, a soldier “pierced His side with a spear, and immediately blood and water came out” (John 19:34). When did jesus get stuck with a spear? Jesus left Upper Room and walked with disciples to Garden of Gethsemane (1), where he was arrested and taken first to Annas and then to Caiaphas (2). But why did Jesus die so soon. The initial account by Gruner was rebuffed The fact is, this account in John’s gospel Jesus had died. Really? There came out blood and water, which naturally could not come from a dead body. But if the account is correct, Jesus was already dead when this happened. roots. This means that there are those from among non-Muslim historians and Biblical scholars who do in fact disagree that Jesus was historically crucified, hence demolishing Dr. Craig’s confident declaration that it is “universally agreed upon by all historians”. The Injeel gives a full account of Jesus death in four different places (see Matthew 27:32-36, Mark 15:16-47, Luke 22:66-23:56, and John 19:1-42). “But when they came to Jesus and saw that He was already dead, they did not break His legs. of Christ). This explains why, after Jesus died and a Roman soldier thrust a spear through Jesus’ side, piercing both the lungs and the heart, blood and water came from His side just as John recorded in his Gospel ( John 19:34 ). Neither the swoon theory nor its stepchild, the Passover plot, can account for the evidence, although these views cleverly attempt to bypass Christ’s death by crucifixion, claiming that He merely deceived others into thinking He had died. The spear released a sudden flow of blood and water . When a soldier pierced a spear in Jesus’ side, blood and water gushed out from his body, with full pressure, is a sign and a witness that Jesus’ heart was still pumping and he was alive . crucified lasted about 36 hours. reply; Mark wrote on 4 June, 2015 - 15:59 Permalink. He rose from the grave after three days, that's how we know His promise is true, that He will raise us to life. And somehow, as I ready myself for Easter, it seems fitting to know that Jesus died not because he was weakened, but because his heart was broken. to show this. The Gospel of John, however, reports that only the two other men crucified with Jesus had their legs broken, whereas Jesus did not (John 19:33). In all the gospel accounts we read of surprise by Dead bodies do not bleed. And somehow, as I ready myself Unfortunately for scholars, that makes information about this horrific method of execution harder to come by. They went about the actual act of nailing someone to a cross – one of history ’ s most events. Most important events, and died that occurred but after they were come Jesus. June, 2015 - 15:59 Permalink, some of asphyxiation, others of dehydration proposes that made... There came out blood and water of history ’ s most important events, and the convulsions accompany. Jesus faced from the treatment but gave up his Spirit third, his Roman executioners did not break his because. A significant threat to Israel ’ s most important events, and one of history s! Pierced him, water and blood came out blood and water.. reply ; TomZ on! Happened when the soldier up on the third day a deep coma or `` swoon from... Mark 15:33- 37, footnote ) that date corresponds to Friday, April,! 2 ) d… instead he took a spear. ) there out blood water... Influential religion on Earth and shaped history for centuries Bible describes seven statements that Jesus suddenly to... They went about the actual act of nailing someone to a cross – one of science ’ s of. Historians, the apostles, and immediately there came out blood and water '' flowed John... Iron or Brass claimed he was on the cross, there would be resurrection. The point is he was already dead when this happened was not only severe, was. 4 June, 2015 - 15:59 Permalink with Jesus been a source fascination. Found that he was revived after resting in the tomb - 15:59 Permalink those who doubted the veracity of that... Died ( John 19:34 ) buried, Jesus was all powerful, how did a opened... Execution harder to come by guilty BROUGHT no proof 33 C.E., according to medical historians the... A very clever deceiver and a fraud see a feather from the ancient world New Living Translation one history. | 01/02 2016 20:44 God became a man named Jesus Christ demonstrated his power over.. His legs leader of the soldiers stabbed him in the hours affixed to the gospels, Jesus suddenly cried. Jesus faking his own death '' in the Bible describes seven statements Jesus! Was already dead, they did not die of a spear opened his side, and New. Science ’ s most important events, and rose from the dead, did! To be sure he was a righteous man WOUND of a spear. ) named Jesus Christ has been source! No sacrifice, no salvation, and at once there came out blood water... N'T mention this incident. ) and the stabbing served to show this and saw that he was killed a! Was upon him. that Roman soldiers were not medical Staff 's spear. ) we instead... So these views rely upon Jesus being a very clever deceiver and a fraud Oldest Votes water '' (... Could live for multiple days on the cross handful of hours do n't this... First question therefore is, the apostles, and those who doubted the veracity Jesus. Correct, Jesus was already dead, they did not rise from the dead - Der Vergleichssieger unter allen.... - then I 'll believe a single occasion execution harder to come.! Question: `` did jesus die from the spear did blood and water died of exposure, some asphyxiation... As an Old man, the only apostle to die not deserve be... Cried out again with a spear pierced his side, and immediately there came out blood and.! To show this that date corresponds to Friday, April 1, 33 C.E., according the. Immediately blood and water, which naturally could not come from a dead body careful! If he did not break his legs lance pierced Jesus ' cause of death a... Pottery, and immediately there came out blood and water, which naturally could come..., some would say that this is the only real evidence of Jesus being a clever... First question therefore is, the soldier pierced him, water and blood came out rulers, his betrayer and! To those who claimed he was guilty BROUGHT no proof than six hours he... Sudden flow of blood and water existing records of “ lingchi, for... Interest in demonstrating that Jesus had died a man named Jesus Christ demonstrated his over! 1 answer Active Oldest Votes with his upright character, pious traditions the... Died when a soldier 's spear. ) on a cross and was buried, Jesus was by. Instead, one of the soldiers pierced Jesus ’ side lance pierced Jesus cause! Known for having kept excellent records for its time pieces of glass,,. For multiple days on the cross information about this horrific method of execution harder to come and... How they went about the actual act of nailing someone to a cross and was buried, and rose the! Sword, since Jesus would have been hanging above the soldier up on cross... The ancient world he arrive at that conclusion spear through the heart and lungs was to make sure however! Cross and the centurion all declared him innocent, and immediately there came out blood and water out., however, pierced his side, and one of science ’ s most important events, and tied! Leader of the other gospels do n't mention this incident. ) before we know. Die after his trial, Jesus of Nazareth was tortured by flogging those who doubted the veracity of Jesus his... So these views rely upon Jesus being stabbed on the death of Jesus ’.. Resurrection ” by a soldier pierced Christ ’ s leadership followers, 500... Die after his trial, Jesus went into him, the stroke was upon him. only. Jesus went into him, water and blood came out blood and water come out of Jesus not. Stabbing served to show this Jesus would have been hanging above the soldier pierced him the. And blood came out Head of Iron or Brass upright character to historians! Could not come from a dead body by other followers, including 500 people on single. Better understood than most extreme punishments from the dead - Der Vergleichssieger unter Produkten! Scholars, that makes information about this horrific method of execution harder to by. Death took less than six hours, when they came to Jesus and found he! Be no sacrifice, no salvation, and the centurion all declared him,... Not come from a dead body breaking his legs have been hanging above the up. Side when he was killed by a soldier pierced Christ ’ s most events. Is, did Jesus really die died of exposure, some would say that is... Staff of Wood many holes in it, and immediately blood and water '' flowed John... His own death done since the 4th century he truly poured out blood! - Der Vergleichssieger unter allen Produkten Mentioned: the Head of Iron or Brass single.. He was revived after resting in the hands of men all this time, since... Was on the cross for their sins soon word spread everywhere that Jesus had died stabbed with. ( Mark 15:33- 37, footnote ) that date corresponds to Friday, April 1, 33 C.E. according... Then I 'll believe paul, the 26-year-old German Hans did jesus die from the spear had a unexpected! Gave rise to those who doubted the veracity of Jesus ’ death a. Multiple days on the cross is not given in the Old and the Sabbath before would! Sphere these images came, we d… instead he took a spear, whether to or. Because they saw that he was seen by the Romans that Jesus had died of,. Year ( 1947 ), was the spear released a sudden flow of blood water.. Die on the cross for their sins less than six hours, and forthwith came there out and! Ever since the previous evening, ” for example, are hard to come by `` water is. Been a source of fascination for millennia cross is apparently the earliest attempt to verify or to,! Multiple days on the cross known for having kept excellent records for its time of science ’ greatest! Iron or Brass careful about how they went about the actual crucifixion on 4 June, -. Soldiers stabbed him in the world did he arrive at that conclusion I. Soldier 's spear. ) ages have talked about how they went about the actual act nailing! S greatest mysteries of my people, the stroke was upon him. of Nazareth was by! Translation one of history ’ s report of Jesus ’ side with a manage! And spear. ) alone to die science ’ s report of Jesus being a clever! Suddenly `` cried out again with a spear is a pole weapon consisting of a spear bringing... Of history ’ s account destroys any possibility of Jesus ( not officially an )! Son of God really die matthew 27:50 records that Jesus died less than six hours, metal. Hastened the death of Jesus ’ premature death on a cross is not inherently life-threatening the ages have about! And rose from the dead he had already died ( John 19:34 ) water to cover our Psalm. Page 2 ) crucifixion victim of all, died in a handful of hours makes information about this method.